← All Modules
Module 7 · Adult Formation
Part A of 2

Now What?

Six modules in. Here is what they add up to — and the question they leave you with.

A The Case, Complete B The Decision in Front of You

Somewhere around Module 3 "What is the Church?" a pattern started to emerge. The evidence was not pointing in multiple directions. It was pointing in one.

Not because Catholicism is obviously true the same way two plus two equals four. But because the claims of the Catholic faith, when taken seriously and examined honestly, turn out to have a remarkable amount of historical, philosophical, and theological weight behind them. Weight that is hard to shake when considering where it all stems from.

This module does not recap what you have covered. It asks a different question: when you lay the full picture out, what does it add up to? What does being a part of this community really mean?

Watch First Why Be Catholic and Not Just Christian? — Trent Horn Catholic Answers · Truthly
What the Evidence Actually Shows

The case for Catholicism doesn't rest on any single argument. It rests on a cumulative one — a set of claims that, taken together, are harder to dismiss than any one of them individually. What follows is that case laid out as a whole, not as a summary of what you've read, but as the argument itself.

I

Jesus was a real historical figure who made claims no sane person makes about himself

The historicity of Jesus is not seriously disputed by scholars. What he claimed about himself — to forgive sins, to be one with the Father, to be the resurrection and the life — is either true, delusional, or a deliberate lie. The Resurrection is the event that forces the question. It is unusually well attested for an ancient event, and even its earliest opponents, who said the body had been stolen, took for granted that the tomb was empty (Matthew 28:13), and it is the hinge on which everything else turns. If the Resurrection happened, the implications are unavoidable. If it didn't, none of the rest of this matters.

II

The Church that built itself on that claim did so at enormous personal cost

The first Christians didn't gain money, power, or social standing by following Jesus. They gained persecution, exile, and in many cases death. Tradition holds that every one of the Apostles except John died as a martyr. The early Church spread not through coercion but through witness — people who had seen something, or who knew people who had seen something, and who refused to recant it even under torture. People do not die for what they know to be a lie. The willingness of the first generation to die for the Resurrection is itself a significant piece of evidence for it.

III

That Church has an unbroken line back to the Apostles themselves

The Church teaches that its bishops succeed the Apostles through an unbroken chain of laying-on-of-hands (CCC 861–862). Written records of individual ordinations do not reach all the way back, but by the second century, writers like St. Irenaeus were already listing the succession of bishops in the great churches back to the Apostles. The Catholic Church did not emerge from the Reformation in the sixteenth century, or from a nineteenth-century revival, or from a founder's personal interpretation of Scripture. It is the original community, continuous with the one Jesus established when he said to Peter: "upon this rock I will build my church" (Matthew 16:18). The Orthodox churches, which separated from Rome in 1054, also preserve apostolic succession, and the Catholic Church recognizes their communion with it as "so profound" that it lacks little (CCC 838). The Protestant churches came out of the Western Church in the sixteenth century.

IV

The sacramental system it developed encodes the logic of the Incarnation

God became physical. He took on a body, ate food, touched lepers, wept at a tomb. The Catholic insistence that grace comes through physical means — water, oil, bread, words spoken by a human voice — is not primitive superstition. It is the consistent application of the Incarnation's logic. If God was willing to enter matter to save us, it makes sense that he would continue to work through matter. The sacraments are the Incarnation extended forward through time.

V

The prayer life it teaches is a relationship, not a ritual

Catholic prayer at its best is not rote recitation. It is conversation with a God who knows you by name, who invites you to bring everything — the gratitude, the failure, the hope, the unanswered question — and who responds not always in the way you expect but in ways that, over time, shape a person unmistakably. The tradition has produced an extraordinary number of serious people of prayer. That is not an accident of culture. It is the fruit of a genuine encounter with a real God.

VI

The communion it offers extends across death itself

You are not joining a local community of a few hundred people. You are joining the Body of Christ — everyone who has ever been baptized into it, living and dead. The saints are not legends. They are your brothers and sisters who finished the race before you, who are already where you are trying to go, and who are available to pray for you from the most advantageous position possible: the presence of God himself. The Church is larger than it appears from the outside. Much larger.

The Question This Leaves You With
What the Evidence Points To

At some point the question stops being "is this plausible?" and becomes "what am I going to do about it?"

Lewis put it this way: Christianity, if false, is of no importance. If true, it is of infinite importance. The one thing it cannot be is moderately important. You cannot treat the Resurrection as an interesting historical curiosity and go on with your life unchanged. Either it happened — in which case everything is different — or it didn't, and none of this matters at all.

The cumulative case for Catholicism doesn't prove anything in the way a mathematical proof does. It never will. Faith is not the conclusion of a logical syllogism. It is a gift of God and a free response to him, and the evidence — historical evidence, philosophical evidence, the evidence of two thousand years of transformed lives — shows that the response is reasonable.

No one gets the kind of certainty a math proof gives. Not the Apostles, not Augustine, not Thomas Aquinas. The certainty of faith is a different kind: the Church says faith is "more certain than all human knowledge because it is founded on the very word of God who cannot lie" (CCC 157). What the saints had was a response to the person of Jesus and the willingness to say yes. That is still what is being asked. Not a proof. Willingness.

I believe in Christianity as I believe that the sun has risen: not only because I see it, but because by it I see everything else.

— C.S. Lewis, "Is Theology Poetry?" 1944

Part B addresses the two people who may be reading this right now. The person deciding whether to take the next step toward the Church — and the person who is already confirmed and came to this track to go deeper. Both of you have something in front of you. Part B is about what that actually looks like.

Module 7 · Part A complete — The Case, Complete
Continue to Part B →